Archeologia e Calcolatori Archeologia e Calcolatori
National Research Council Istituto di Studi sul Mediterraneo Antico
Dipartimento Scienze Umane e Sociali, Patrimonio Culturale
Journal

Journal established by: Mauro Cristofani and Riccardo Francovich
Editor: Paola Moscati

Authors Cowgill, G.L. -
Title Getting Bayesian ideas across to a wide audience
Volume Archeologia e Calcolatori n. XIII - 2002
In Djindjian F., Moscati P. (eds.) XIV UISPP Congress (Liège - Belgium 2001). Proceedings of Commission IV Symposia. Data Management and Mathematical Methods in Archaeology
Pages pp. 191-196
URL http://www.archcalc.cnr.it/indice/PDF13/13Cowgill.pdf
Publisher Edizioni All'Insegna del Giglio
Subject Statistics
Subject Theoretical and methodological problems
Abstract A generally Bayesian attitude toward statistical inference seems to me so obviously superior to the “classical” Neyman-Pearson approach that it is difficult to comprehend why not everyone agrees. I believe that most non-statisticians learn classical procedures ritualistically but then interpret their results in naively Bayesian ways. It would be better if they became more sophisticated and knowing Bayesians. A truly introductory text on the logic of Bayesian inference, with some simple but useful applications, would probably help. Bayesian inference with an uninformative prior may yield the same results as classical inference, but with coherent rather than muddled logic. An example of a very useful but mathematically simple archaeological application of an informative prior is using prior information to improve estimates of true proportions of artifact categories in populations represented by small collections. However, a complication arises when the observed proportion in a fairly large sample is well outside the range considered at all likely for the relevant population, based on prior information. In this case, straightforward use of a beta prior distribution can yield results that seem unreasonable. Possibly our prior information is better represented by a modified beta distribution with “heavy” tails. Advice about this problem would be appreciated.
Language ENG Type text

Licenza Creative Commons

Software ISMA
Editorial address:
"Archeologia e Calcolatori",
c/o Istituto di Studi sul Mediterraneo Antico del C.N.R.,
Via Salaria Km 29,300 c.p. 10 - 00016 Monterotondo (Roma) - Italy.
Tel. +39 06 90672460 / 90672727; Fax +39 06 90672818
E-mail paola.moscati@isma.cnr.it
Publishers and Distribution:
Edizioni All'Insegna del Giglio s.a.s.,
Via del Termine 36,
50019 Sesto Fiorentino (FI) - ITALY
Tel. ++39-055-8450216; FAX ++39-055-8453188
E-mail info@edigiglio.it